Saturday, March 20, 2010

Prompt 3 -- The House and the Farm


Rudolfo Anaya’s bildungsroman, Bless Me Ultima, details the growth and maturation of a Mexican-American boy named Antonio “Tony” Marez in New Mexico during the 1940s. Tony spends much of the novel on the receiving end of pressure from his mother to grow up and become a Catholic priest and from his father to grow up and continue the family tradition of horsemanship. The opposition each of Tony’s parents comes to experience from the other is reflected in the contrast between the llano Tony’s father built the family’s house on, and the farm owned and operated by Tony’s maternal uncles; as Tony grows up and attempts to find himself spiritually and culturally, the merits and faults of both places come to serve Tony’s development into a young man capable of following his own beliefs and goals.

The Marez family’s house on the llano is a piece of architecture crafted by Tony’s father and slightly isolated from the town in which Tony goes to school. This isolation from the rest of the town is often a source of distress from Tony’s mother, who insists that it was foolish to build the house out in the fields as opposed to the town itself. And despite his defensiveness to Tony’s mother, Tony’s father himself seems discontent with the house; he dreams of moving himself and his sons to a place where his dream of keeping the vaquero (cowboy) lifestyle alive is possible, which was the initial purpose of the house he built on the llano. These dreams prove impossible, though, and by the end of the novel, Tony’s father comes to terms with the fact that his cowboy lifestyle cannot be assimilated into American life – a fact that had always been symbolized by the house’s isolation from the assimilated town.

Aside from his own house, Tony also spends a significant amount of time in the novel at his uncles’ farm in another town. In contrast to Tony’s house, the farm is more immersed in the town and, rather than being the product of one man’s hands, has been shared by Tony’s mother’s family from generation to generation. The nature of the lifestyle the farm reflects also contrasts that of the Marez house; whereas the house is essentially the swan song of the dying vaquero lifestyle, the farm is a source of prosperity for Tony’s uncles, grounded in family and tradition. Within that understanding, Tony’s mother’s desire for her son to pursue priesthood in the Catholic tradition is a fitting extension of what the farm represents. However, that this farm and the opportunities it presents Tony clashes with what Tony’s father hopes for him ironically generates conflict in Tony about the sense of family the farm embodies.

Components of both places ultimately play fundamental roles in Tony’s development as a character; a spiritual guide named Ultima takes advantage of the Marez house’s isolation to guide Tony’s understanding of nature, and uses the same concept of growth and life-giving at the farm to build on that understanding. Numerous traumatic events at both places, including a series of murders and an exorcism, advance Tony’s spiritual development as well. In essence, the wide variety of experiences and different conditions associated with the house and the farm come to mold Tony not merely into a product of only the house or only the farm, but a product of both, who is capable of continuing to grow as a person.

7 comments:

  1. Family politics in Catholic families is always interesting.

    One thing: What does "llano" mean? I was reading the first paragraph and then here's this italicised word and I'm all like whoa man. I like how you used Spanish words--I get the feeling that you had to, because they probably carried a lot of emotional connotations in the book. I also liked how you talked about the different directions that each side of the family pulled Tony in, but how did he feel about it all?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Interesting book, I kind of want to read it now ^^
    I liked the essay overall. Good word choice and organization.
    I agree with Sarah about "ilano" though. I was a little confused on why being a Catholic priest might help Tony to assimilate into society, but I'm thinking it's just a cultural thing I don't understand.

    ReplyDelete
  3. FYI: Llano simply means "plain", like a praire or open field. It has actually been incorporated into english. The open flatland in the American Southwest is referred to as the llano, which is the setting for this novel. :]

    I really liked your essay! The only thing I would add would be how in the beginning of the novel Tony wanted to fulfill his mother's dreams and wanted to please his mother. This is shown when Tony spend hours trying to make his mother a garden out of the rock llano soil.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Great job Noah! This book seems very interesting! I like how you had a very good hook in the introduction, helps the reader to begin to find interest in what they are about to read!
    Question, like everyone else asked, What does Llano mean?

    I think its interested how you compared spirtually and culturally and how it helped Tony to grow as a person. I wouldn't have thought about comparing those two. Great job thinking outside the box :)

    ReplyDelete
  5. hahaha you and your Mexican books >.<
    Makes me want to learn more. It's amazing how much setting can effect a person's growth

    ReplyDelete
  6. Noah~

    1) I think it's really interesting how there seem to be two sets of opposing forces that you talk about: becoming a catholic priest vs. continuing horsemanship being one conflict, and the llano where the house is vs. the farm Tony's uncles own and operate. It wouldn't seem like those two sets of opposing forces would even correlate with each other, but you explain how they do. It really helps to understand where this book is coming from.
    2) Your paragraph on the house on the llano was very interesting to me. I liked how it showed how the father wanted to keep the vaquero lifestyle alive but in the end wasn't able to do that. The house itself seems to represent a broken dream or dream that will never come true. It is almost like a sore reminder of that dream, and it's no wonder why the father would want to leave it. Very interesting analysis :)
    3) Your analogies for each place you describe are very enlightening. It helps me to understand exactly where you are coming from and how it can be seen through their eyes. It also shows that you have a great insight on the book and how the characters think and that you are able to put it into terms that other readers that don't have that insight will be able to understand. Awesome :)
    4) As a whole I really enjoyed reading your essay. There were times while I was reading when I was like "Oh wow! I never thought of it that way!" and I like being able to get that out of reading something. Your understanding on the topic of this book and everything that this novel embodies makes me want to read it and understand it more. I'm hooked :)

    Excellente :)

    ReplyDelete
  7. Noah. I loved this essay. I really liked how you were really able to show how important place is in the novel, and I really liked how I could tell that you liked this book based on the types of descriptions you used. I also appreciated just how much detail you had in the essay. It was like you had the book open next to you. Great job! =)

    ReplyDelete